SAN ANTONIO – A Texas state trooper accused of wrongfully killing a man in Converse after a pursuit exercised his right to remain silent more than 150 times while being questioned under oath, according to records obtained by KSAT Investigates.
Department of Public Safety records confirmed trooper Apolonio Gomez fatally shot Luis Navarro in April 2024 after a chase that ended in a crash.
Gomez has been a DPS trooper for more than seven years.
While Gomez is not facing any charges, he has been named in a wrongful death lawsuit filed by Navarro’s family.
As part of that lawsuit, Gomez was questioned about the shooting and previous incidents under oath during a December 2024 deposition.
In previous court filings, Gomez defended his actions.
Jeff Edwards, a lawyer representing the Navarro family in the federal lawsuit, questioned Gomez for nearly three hours.
Pleading the Fifth more than 150 times
Edwards showed Gomez witness videos obtained by KSAT of the fatal shooting.
The April 2024 incident began in New Braunfels. DPS said Gomez tried to pull Navarro over, who instead led Gomez on a high-speed chase.
The chase ended after DPS said Navarro crashed into another car on Loop 1604 in Converse.
Gomez tried to shock Navarro with a Taser, but DPS said the Taser didn’t work.
In May 2024, KSAT Investigates learned Navarro had a warrant for his arrest.
Witnesses and Navarro’s family told KSAT they believed Gomez should have used less force.
The video shows Navarro holding a t-shirt in one hand, with both arms extended in front of him.
DPS has refused to answer if Navarro had a weapon at the time of the shooting.
“In that video, you can observe that you shot Mr. Navarro while he was unarmed,” said Edwards. “Isn’t that correct?”
Gomez’s attorney objected.
“Based upon the advice of my counsel, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to answer that question,” responded Gomez.
During the questioning, Gomez revealed he had his body camera on during the shooting. KSAT has requested the video, but DPS has asked the state attorney general’s office to withhold the footage.
“Do you recall Mr. Navarro telling you to tell his children that he loved them after you had shot him?” Edwards asked.
“On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to answer that question,” Gomez replied.
Gomez exercised his right to remain silent more than 150 times, according to a deposition transcript.
‘I don’t know the laws of Mexico’
Records obtained by KSAT Investigates revealed Gomez had previously been reprimanded for another deputy chase.
DPS suspended Gomez for 10 days without pay for an unauthorized 2023 chase from El Paso into Mexico.
Dash camera video from that chase showed Gomez passing several signs, including a warning sign that indicated he was leaving the United States and a big blue sign that read “Welcome to Mexico.”
The chase ended in the Mexican customs facilities two minutes after it began in El Paso.
Records revealed that Gomez shared dash camera video of the chase in a group text with other troopers. The clip was later leaked on social media.
“So you think you were wrong to do it?” Edwards asked Gomez.
“I was wrong on the basis of — It’s a policy violation,” Gomez responded.
Assistant Attorney General Christopher Lindsey, who is also representing Gomez in the lawsuit, declined to comment on the story because the case is still pending.
DPS Sgt. Kenny Mata also declined comment for this story but added that the deputy shooting remains under investigation.
More related coverage of this story on KSAT:
