Appeals court says state agency set electricity prices too high during 2021 winter storm

AUSTIN (Texas Tribune) — A Texas appellate court surprised the electricity world Friday by ruling that the Public Utility Commission overstepped its authority during the deadly February 2021 winter storm when it raised the price of electricity to the maximum, $9,000 per megawatt-hour.

The price was set that high on Feb. 15 and Feb. 16 by the commission in charge of regulating Texas’ electricity in an effort to tell the market that more power generation was urgently needed. Its leadership believed that the financial tool meant to adjust the cost of electricity was malfunctioning as electricity generators had fallen offline and grid operators cut power to homes and businesses, the ruling explains.

The price of electricity is fluid in Texas; it goes up when demand is high in order to incentivize more production and keep the grid from being overloaded. But the state’s electricity market monitor said in the aftermath of the storm that Texas overcharged retail electricity providers by $16 billion for the power that they then pass on to the residents and businesses throughout the state.

The electric utility Luminant appealed the pricing decisions in the month after the storm. It argued that the commission exceeded its authority in setting the price at the maximum, among other points. The Austin-based Third Court of Appeals agreed in the ruling it issued Friday. But the consequences for its decision were not immediately clear, as the court remanded the case for further consideration.

The Public Utility Commission declined to comment.

This developing story. Check back with the Texas Tribune for updates.

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at www.texastribune.org.  The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans – and engages with them – about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

 

Congress Ave. during Winter Storm Uri in Austin on Feb. 16, 2021. Credit: Jordan Vonderhaar for The Texas Tribune
Congress Ave. during Winter Storm Uri in Austin on Feb. 16, 2021. Credit: Jordan Vonderhaar for The Texas Tribune

The actions by the Public Utility Commission led to billions of dollars of overcharges, the Austin-based court found. It’s not yet clear if the ruling will affect consumers.

AUSTIN (Texas Tribune) — A Texas appellate court surprised the electricity world Friday by ruling that the Public Utility Commission overstepped its authority during the deadly February 2021 winter storm when it raised the price of electricity to the maximum, $9,000 per megawatt-hour.

The price was set that high on Feb. 15 and Feb. 16 by the commission in charge of regulating Texas’ electricity in an effort to tell the market that more power generation was urgently needed. Its leadership believed that the financial tool meant to adjust the cost of electricity was malfunctioning as electricity generators had fallen offline and grid operators cut power to homes and businesses, the ruling explains.

The price of electricity is fluid in Texas; it goes up when demand is high in order to incentivize more production and keep the grid from being overloaded. But the state’s electricity market monitor said in the aftermath of the storm that Texas overcharged retail electricity providers by $16 billion for the power that they then pass on to the residents and businesses throughout the state.

The electric utility Luminant appealed the pricing decisions in the month after the storm. It argued that the commission exceeded its authority in setting the price at the maximum, among other points. The Austin-based Third Court of Appeals agreed in the ruling it issued Friday. But the consequences for its decision were not immediately clear, as the court remanded the case for further consideration.

The Public Utility Commission declined to comment.

This developing story. Check back with the Texas Tribune for updates.

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at www.texastribune.org.  The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans – and engages with them – about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

<article class="article-list__article" data-article-id="1688398" data-index="0" data-collection="article-list1" data-anvato-params=""pauseOnTabInactive":false
// –>

Tracking the Coronavirus


What is the current COVID risk in your county?

/ 1 day ago

Austin Weather

Current

49°

Cloudy

Tonight

40°

Scattered Showers Late

Precip: 20&percnt;

Tomorrow

55°

Showers South, Some Flakes

Precip: 30&percnt;

Trending Stories


The legality of shooting dogs in Texas


Trump to visit Central Texas for 1st 2024 rally


Chance of snow for some to start the weekend


Texans waiting months for driver licenses


6 from Texas charged in $111M IRS fraud scheme

Don’t Miss


RESULTS: This is the best KXAN viewer pic of February


2023 SXSW festival road closures, travel info


The story of 12 students who integrated ATX schools


170K AE customers without power at ice storm peak


KXAN launches new news podcasts



Latest weather conditions from the KXAN First Warning Weather team