Austin’s ‘Heritage Tree’ rules unclear for homeowners seeking to trim branches

AUSTIN (KXAN) — Last week’s ice storm felled many trees and dropped branches, sometimes pulling down power lines and blocking accessways, leading to questions about preventative trimming.

Kelsey Vance, an Austin resident, says that branches from two large trees pulled down her power lines and dropped branches on her home during last week’s ice storm.

She says that she tried to prevent this in 2021, asking the city to trim trees near her electrical lines. City workers did remove some smaller trees, Vance said, but they left the largest trees untouched.

“Those were the ones I had the biggest concern about because of how big they are,” Vance said. “I talked to the arborist and he was like, ‘Well, those are, those are heritage trees, so we can’t touch them, you’ll have to work with the city to understand what you need to do with those.'”

The city arborist’s office, a part of the City of Austin’s Developmental Services Department, defines heritage trees as having a diameter of at least 24 inches and of a specific species: any oak, Arizona Walnut, American Elm, Bald Cypress, Bigtooth Maple, Cedar Elm, Eastern Black Walnut, Pecan, Texas Ash or Texas Madrone.


Wildflower Center battered by winter ice storm, but looks ahead for spring blooms

Under the city ordinances, these trees cannot be removed unless the tree “is dead or is a hazard to life or property.” In such cases, property owners must submit a permit application and related fees to the city arborist before removing the trees.

But for Vance and others who want to trim their trees, the rules become opaque.

“I tried to submit a request, just to have…a consult based on you know, fire hazard, and I also mentioned the electrical lines,” Vance said. “I was, in my case, assigned to an arborist. However, he responded to me saying, ‘you know, we need more information, your case isn’t closed.'”

Vance sent that extra info but never heard back. She tried, over the course of several months, to follow up via weekly calls and email requests. However, nothing happened; she gave up for a while.

Then, she received an email in October 2022 about Austin’s “Tree Smart” classes. She went with her father, and they approached a city employee after the session.

“They just kind of never answered a question, and told us we needed to go back to the arborist,” Vance said. “What I’m struggling with from these heritage trees is getting information on what can be done to keep the trees trimmed so they’re not impeding the electrical lines. Because that ultimately [was] one of those tree limbs pulled my electrical lines off of the side of the house.”


Oak wilt poses a threat to Texas live oaks after ice storm, arborists warn

The heritage trees in Vance’s yard are still standing, and still have branches looming over the power lines. She hopes that the city will start to take more notice of residents like her, and offer better information about heritage tree trimming.

“There’s no information that’s helpful to us homeowners who have those heritage trees on their property and don’t necessarily want to do anything with them,” Vance said. “Maybe the city just needs to come out and see if there is, in fact, a fire hazard. There’s just no roadmap for those kinds of situations that I have come across.”

KXAN reached out to the city arborist for an interview but did not hear back in time.

 

A Heritage Tree toppled over during last week’s ice storm. (KXAN Photos/Todd Bynum)
A Heritage Tree toppled over during last week’s ice storm. (KXAN Photos/Todd Bynum)

AUSTIN (KXAN) — Last week’s ice storm felled many trees and dropped branches, sometimes pulling down power lines and blocking accessways, leading to questions about preventative trimming.

Kelsey Vance, an Austin resident, says that branches from two large trees pulled down her power lines and dropped branches on her home during last week’s ice storm.

She says that she tried to prevent this in 2021, asking the city to trim trees near her electrical lines. City workers did remove some smaller trees, Vance said, but they left the largest trees untouched.

“Those were the ones I had the biggest concern about because of how big they are,” Vance said. “I talked to the arborist and he was like, ‘Well, those are, those are heritage trees, so we can’t touch them, you’ll have to work with the city to understand what you need to do with those.’”

The city arborist’s office, a part of the City of Austin’s Developmental Services Department, defines heritage trees as having a diameter of at least 24 inches and of a specific species: any oak, Arizona Walnut, American Elm, Bald Cypress, Bigtooth Maple, Cedar Elm, Eastern Black Walnut, Pecan, Texas Ash or Texas Madrone.


Wildflower Center battered by winter ice storm, but looks ahead for spring blooms

Under the city ordinances, these trees cannot be removed unless the tree “is dead or is a hazard to life or property.” In such cases, property owners must submit a permit application and related fees to the city arborist before removing the trees.

But for Vance and others who want to trim their trees, the rules become opaque.

“I tried to submit a request, just to have…a consult based on you know, fire hazard, and I also mentioned the electrical lines,” Vance said. “I was, in my case, assigned to an arborist. However, he responded to me saying, ‘you know, we need more information, your case isn’t closed.’”

Vance sent that extra info but never heard back. She tried, over the course of several months, to follow up via weekly calls and email requests. However, nothing happened; she gave up for a while.

Then, she received an email in October 2022 about Austin’s “Tree Smart” classes. She went with her father, and they approached a city employee after the session.

“They just kind of never answered a question, and told us we needed to go back to the arborist,” Vance said. “What I’m struggling with from these heritage trees is getting information on what can be done to keep the trees trimmed so they’re not impeding the electrical lines. Because that ultimately [was] one of those tree limbs pulled my electrical lines off of the side of the house.”


Oak wilt poses a threat to Texas live oaks after ice storm, arborists warn

The heritage trees in Vance’s yard are still standing, and still have branches looming over the power lines. She hopes that the city will start to take more notice of residents like her, and offer better information about heritage tree trimming.

“There’s no information that’s helpful to us homeowners who have those heritage trees on their property and don’t necessarily want to do anything with them,” Vance said. “Maybe the city just needs to come out and see if there is, in fact, a fire hazard. There’s just no roadmap for those kinds of situations that I have come across.”

KXAN reached out to the city arborist for an interview but did not hear back in time.

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Best products for keeping young kids busy during …

/ 4 hours ago

To keep kids occupied during the Super Bowl, you’ll want to have activities prepared so you can focus on cheering your team on to another victory.


What is the history behind the teddy bear?

/ 8 hours ago

Here’s everything you need to know about the history of the teddy bear and the best ones to gift this year.


Everything your pet needs for winter

/ 8 hours ago

As winter blows on, it’s past time to think about what your pets need to stay warm and safe.


View All BestReviews


Top Stories


LIST: Power positions announced for TX representatives


Horns projected to be on the road for NCAA regional


5 Longhorns invited to NFL Scouting Combine


300-job knife factory, HQ project dies in Leander


Austin offers resources, support for storm recovery


Top Stories


More Stories


Horns projected to be on the road for NCAA regional


5 Longhorns invited to NFL Scouting Combine


300-job knife factory, HQ project dies in Leander


Austin offers resources, support for storm recovery


Central TX tree debris requests increase to 18k+


Man convicted of murder for 2021 incident in N. Austin


What are Austin’s Heritage Trees?


Austin café sells all of its $150-per-cup coffee


More Stories

Austin-Travis County


Horns projected to be on the road for NCAA regional

/ 22 mins ago


5 Longhorns invited to NFL Scouting Combine

/ 30 mins ago


Austin offers resources, support for storm recovery

/ 45 mins ago


Central TX tree debris requests increase to 18k+

/ 56 mins ago


Man convicted of murder for 2021 incident in N. Austin

/ 1 hour ago


What are Austin’s Heritage Trees?

/ 1 hour ago


Austin café sells all of its $150-per-cup coffee

/ 1 hour ago


Jericho Sims to participate in NBA Slam Dunk Contest

/ 2 hours ago


Sunshine returns, but swings in temperature coming

/ 57 mins ago


Texas water crisis: $2.4M announced for new research

/ 3 hours ago


Wildflower Center battered by winter ice storm

/ 3 hours ago


Suspicious death reported in east Austin

/ 3 hours ago


Police identify person killed in 10-vehicle crash

/ 2 hours ago


Passenger dies in single-vehicle crash

/ 5 hours ago


Not many Texans have started at QB in Super Bowl

/ 6 hours ago


Shelter in place lifted for ACC campus

/ 5 hours ago


Austin ordered to pay $90M in airport expansion suit

/ 6 hours ago


Can I burn my tree stumps, fallen branches post-storm?

/ 6 hours ago


New Orleans homicide suspect arrested in Austin

/ 9 hours ago


APD: 1 dead, 1 hurt after hostage incident

/ 7 hours ago

KXAN Austin Video

<article class="article-list__article article-list__article–is-stacked article-list__article–has-thumb article-list__article–is-media-type" data-article-id="8374318" data-index="0" data-collection="article-list5" data-anvato-params=""ns":"id":"8374318","title":"City of Austin offers resource center to help people struggling from freeze","link":"https://www.kxan.com/video/city-of-austin-offers-resource-center-to-help-people-struggling-from-freeze/8374318/","thumbnail":"src":"https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI","orientation":"landscape","proportional_sources":"16:9":"srcset":"https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 160w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 256w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 320w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 640w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 960w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 1280w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 1920w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/38E/71C/38E71CFB0D8026CD200CA18B19472F18_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=t7zCdLP5LZcEzUdq1m8RTfAfGJI 2560w","sizes":"(max-width: 899px) 100%, 300px","date":"time":"22 mins ago","datetime":"2023-02-08T17:57:17-06:00","lead_media":true,"media_type_icon":"name":"video","label":"Video","vilynx_id":"LIN_8374318","mcp":"LIN","width":"100%","height":"100%","video":"8374318","autoplay":false,"expect_preroll":true,"pInstance":"p48","plugins":"comscore":"clientId":"6036439","c3":"kxan.com","version":"5.2.0","useDerivedMetadata":true,"mapping":"c3":"kxan.com","ns_st_st":"kxan","ns_st_pu":"Nexstar","ns_st_ge":"News,Local,Austin,Video,Local News,Video","cs_ucfr":"","dfp":"adTagUrl":"https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ads?sz=1×1000&iu=/5678/lin.kxan/news/local/austin&impl=s&gdfp_req=1&env=vp&output=vmap&unviewed_position_start=1&ad_rule=1&description_url=https://www.kxan.com/news/local/austin/austins-heritage-tree-rules-unclear-for-homeowners-seeking-to-trim-branches/&cust_params=vid%3D8374318%26cmsid%3D1644313%26pid%3D1644313%26pers_cid%3Dnxs-40-article-1644313%26vidcat%3D/news/local/austin%26bob_ck%3D[bob_ck_val]%26d_code%3D1%26pagetype%3Dstory%26hlmeta%3Daustins%20heritage%20tree%20rules%20unclear%20for%20homeowners%20seeking%20to%20trim%20branches%26aa%3Df","nielsen":"apid":"P74D95DB2-9ACC-40E2-B3B5-7B9C65C50126","sfcode":"dcr","type":"dcr","apn":"Anvato","environment":"production","useDerivedMetadata":true,"mapping":"adloadtype":2,"adModel":2,"segmentCustom":"script":"https://segment.psg.nexstardigital.net/anvato.js","writeKey":"8Jlo8JuUyENFG8nvLkq1NuyT2CHRyOp7","pluginsLoadingTimeout":12,"expectPrerollTimeout":8,"accessKey":"gq261XAmw8b5xi69ku8hYmO1kyPmMBzn","token":"eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJ2aWQiOiI4Mzc0MzE4IiwiaXNzIjoiZ3EyNjFYQW13OGI1eGk2OWt1OGhZbU8xa3lQbU1Cem4iLCJleHAiOjE2NzU5MDU1NDJ9.V5xy94LUgMjQ2VJ2lL28g9ykJe0uwOWs8CV5n72sClI","nxs":"mp4Url":"https://h104216-dcdn.mp.lura.live/1/20005/59/23/02/08/8374318/8374318_3173FA7659EBF2CB43F4DFAE61206B54_230208_8374318_City_of_Austin_offers_resource_center_to_help_pe_1500.mp4","enableFloatingPlayer":true,"disableMutedAutoplay":false,"recommendations":false,"expectPreroll":false,"titleVisible":false,"pauseOnClick":true,"trackTimePeriod":60,"isPermutiveEnabled":true
// –>


Tracking the Coronavirus


COVID-19 tracker: Cases in the KXAN viewing area

/ 4 hours ago


Data tracker: COVID cases, vaccine rates across Texas

/ 4 hours ago


Coronavirus Cases Tracker

Austin Weather

Current

56°

Sunny

Tonight

41°

Mostly Clear

Precip: 0&percnt;

Tomorrow

72°

Mostly Sunny

Precip: 0&percnt;

Trending Stories


Oak wilt threatens Texas oaks after ice storm damage


‘Almost $20K’: Some AE customers to pay out of pocket


Texas passed missing persons reporting law, but does …


Can I burn my tree stumps, fallen branches post-storm?


APD: 1 dead, 1 hurt after hostage incident

Don’t Miss


Why don’t we just bury the power lines?


Cities offer free tree, brush disposals post-storm


Radio signal detected from distant galaxy


TxDMV rejects vegan license plate for ‘vulgar’ phrase


KXAN launches new news podcasts



Latest weather conditions from the KXAN First Warning Weather team