Case dismissed against Austin police officer indicted after 2020 protest

AUSTIN (KXAN) — An indictment against Austin police officer Nicholas Gebhart stemming from the May 2020 downtown Austin protests was dismissed Friday afternoon.

Nicholas Gebhart was indicted on two counts of aggravated assault by a public servant, in the case of an injured teenager named Brad Ayala.


Everything we know about the teen shot in the head with less lethal round at Austin protest

Gebhart’s attorney Doug O’Connell confirmed the dismissal to KXAN. This story will be updated with additional comment when available.

Travis County District Attorney Jose Garza said new evidence and information “significantly complicated” the ability of his office to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

At a press conference Friday, Garza refused to offer further details about what kind of evidence came to light, other than that it would have “significant consequences” for their ability to prove the case, but added that was not the only factor influencing their decision to dismiss the case.

Dexter Gilford, the head of the Civil Rights Division, said Ayala no longer wanted the DA’s office to pursue the case.

“Mr. Ayala has communicated to our office that he no longer wishes our office to proceed with this criminal case. In every case, our office strives to center the voice of the victim in our deliberations on the most appropriate resolution for a criminal case,” Gilford said.

The DA also noted that, “to his knowledge,” Gebhart was the only officer indicted in Ayala’s case.

KXAN is working to find contact information for Ayala’s attorney.

Garza refused to go so far as to say his office no longer believes a crime was committed in this case, but he emphasized this decision and the new evidence is specific to this case and has no bearing on other cases of officers indicted from actions during the protests.

Additionally, he believes there could be “some legal barriers” preventing his office from sharing more information about this evidence.

The indictment said Gebhart shot Ayala, during a racial injustice protest near Interstate 35. Ayala was hit in the head with a “less-lethal” bean bag round, former APD Chief Brian Manley said after the incident. Garza said a “deadly weapon” was used, “specifically a modified shotgun.”

In March 2022, Austin City Council approved the settlement of a personal injury claim by Brad Levi Ayala for $2.95 million and direct the City Manager to return to Council with the necessary resolution and ordinance to finance the settlement.

An official attorney statement was released after the case was dismissed. Read that statement below:

We find it difficult to be thankful Mr. Garza has only now decided to dismiss all criminal
charges against Officer Gebhart.
We’re also unaware of any “new evidence” in the case that allegedly prompted today’s
dismissal. If Mr. Garza is referring to Brad Ayala’s desire for the charges to be dropped,
that’s been known for months. And if he’s referring to footage showing Mr. Ayala
throwing rocks at police seconds before he was impacted with a beanbag, that’s been in
existence since May of 2020.
If Mr. Garza is referring to other “new evidence,” this is equally disturbing since it does
not appear we have been provided the evidence as required by law.
If Mr. Garza is referring to other “new evidence,” this is equally disturbing since it does
not appear we have been provided the evidence as required by law.
We predict more of our police officer cases will be dismissed, and Mr. Garza will again
refuse to tell the public the real reasons.

-Ken Ervin & Doug O’Connell
Attorneys for APD Officer Gebhart 

AUSTIN (KXAN) — An indictment against Austin police officer Nicholas Gebhart stemming from the May 2020 downtown Austin protests was dismissed Friday afternoon.

Nicholas Gebhart was indicted on two counts of aggravated assault by a public servant, in the case of an injured teenager named Brad Ayala.


Everything we know about the teen shot in the head with less lethal round at Austin protest

Gebhart’s attorney Doug O’Connell confirmed the dismissal to KXAN. This story will be updated with additional comment when available.

Travis County District Attorney Jose Garza said new evidence and information “significantly complicated” the ability of his office to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

At a press conference Friday, Garza refused to offer further details about what kind of evidence came to light, other than that it would have “significant consequences” for their ability to prove the case, but added that was not the only factor influencing their decision to dismiss the case.

Dexter Gilford, the head of the Civil Rights Division, said Ayala no longer wanted the DA’s office to pursue the case.

“Mr. Ayala has communicated to our office that he no longer wishes our office to proceed with this criminal case. In every case, our office strives to center the voice of the victim in our deliberations on the most appropriate resolution for a criminal case,” Gilford said.

The DA also noted that, “to his knowledge,” Gebhart was the only officer indicted in Ayala’s case.

KXAN is working to find contact information for Ayala’s attorney.

Garza refused to go so far as to say his office no longer believes a crime was committed in this case, but he emphasized this decision and the new evidence is specific to this case and has no bearing on other cases of officers indicted from actions during the protests.

Additionally, he believes there could be “some legal barriers” preventing his office from sharing more information about this evidence.

The indictment said Gebhart shot Ayala, during a racial injustice protest near Interstate 35. Ayala was hit in the head with a “less-lethal” bean bag round, former APD Chief Brian Manley said after the incident. Garza said a “deadly weapon” was used, “specifically a modified shotgun.”

In March 2022, Austin City Council approved the settlement of a personal injury claim by Brad Levi Ayala for $2.95 million and direct the City Manager to return to Council with the necessary resolution and ordinance to finance the settlement.

An official attorney statement was released after the case was dismissed. Read that statement below:

We find it difficult to be thankful Mr. Garza has only now decided to dismiss all criminalcharges against Officer Gebhart.We’re also unaware of any “new evidence” in the case that allegedly prompted today’sdismissal. If Mr. Garza is referring to Brad Ayala’s desire for the charges to be dropped,that’s been known for months. And if he’s referring to footage showing Mr. Ayalathrowing rocks at police seconds before he was impacted with a beanbag, that’s been inexistence since May of 2020.If Mr. Garza is referring to other “new evidence,” this is equally disturbing since it doesnot appear we have been provided the evidence as required by law.If Mr. Garza is referring to other “new evidence,” this is equally disturbing since it doesnot appear we have been provided the evidence as required by law.We predict more of our police officer cases will be dismissed, and Mr. Garza will againrefuse to tell the public the real reasons.

-Ken Ervin & Doug O’ConnellAttorneys for APD Officer Gebhart

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


5 party foods inspired by past Grammy nominees

/ 20 hours ago

Themed food and drinks are a surefire way to make your party stand out, and looking at past Grammy nominees is a great way to get inspiration.


Love the Grammys? We have everything you’ll need …

/ 20 hours ago

With Grammy night around the corner, here are some fun ways to embrace the theme, boost your entertainment and make your guests feel a part of the festivities.


Best NuFace product

/ 21 hours ago

NuFace devices use low microcurrent voltage similar to natural electric currents in the body and are safe and painless on the skin.


View All BestReviews


Top Stories


Top Black-owned businesses to go to in Austin


A quiet weekend with warming temperatures


Frustrated neighbors still without power in West …


Where you can find resources due to ice storm


Schools across Austin cleaning up downed trees, branches …


Top Stories


More Stories


Top Black-owned businesses to go to in Austin


A quiet weekend with warming temperatures


Frustrated neighbors still without power in West …


Where you can find resources due to ice storm


Schools across Austin cleaning up downed trees, branches …


Senior living facilities still without power


Anderson HS football team cleans up ice storm debris


Jury clears Musk of wrongdoing related to Tesla tweets


More Stories

Austin-Travis County


A quiet weekend with warming temperatures

/ 2 mins ago


Where you can find resources due to ice storm

/ 12 hours ago


Schools across Austin cleaning up downed trees, branches …

/ 12 hours ago


Senior living facilities still without power

/ 13 hours ago


CapMetro cleared roads of debris while services down

/ 15 hours ago


ATCEMS: Crashes mostly at non-working traffic lights

/ 15 hours ago


Case dismissed against officer indicted after protest

/ 12 hours ago


How to see what traffic lights are out in Austin

/ 13 hours ago


Austin Energy ‘cautiously optimistic’ on restoration

/ 12 hours ago


Boil water notices for parts of Hays, Travis, Bastrop

/ 16 hours ago


10-car crash reported on US 183 in north Austin

/ 1 day ago


Why 4 Austin patients were flown out for CO poisoning

/ 15 hours ago


APD: Man dies from injuries after traffic incident

/ 1 day ago


Austin Energy customers want better communication

/ 1 day ago


How vegetation management plays into Austin outages

/ 2 days ago


Shots fired reported at Pflugerville shopping center

/ 14 hours ago


KXAN’s Jim Spencer reflects on historic ice storm

/ 2 days ago


Report: End likely for WGC-Match Play and Austin

/ 2 days ago


2nd victim dies in NW Austin hookah lounge shooting

/ 2 days ago


Tracking medically vulnerable people during outages

/ 2 days ago

KXAN Austin Video

<article class="article-list__article article-list__article–is-stacked article-list__article–has-thumb article-list__article–is-media-type" data-article-id="8362181" data-index="0" data-collection="article-list5" data-anvato-params=""ns":"id":"8362181","title":"Schools across Austin cleaning up downed trees, branches following freeze","link":"https://www.kxan.com/video/schools-across-austin-cleaning-up-downed-trees-branches-following-freeze/8362181/","thumbnail":"src":"https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q","orientation":"landscape","proportional_sources":"16:9":"srcset":"https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 160w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 256w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 320w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 640w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 960w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 1280w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 1920w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/3F1/116/3F1116233910F0E106A05614C32AC57F_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=OnHV6NhAeFfPJ-5r_2kdXEF1S_Q 2560w","sizes":"(max-width: 899px) 100%, 300px","date":"time":"12 hours ago","datetime":"2023-02-03T21:34:02-06:00","lead_media":true,"media_type_icon":"name":"video","label":"Video","vilynx_id":"LIN_8362181","mcp":"LIN","width":"100%","height":"100%","video":"8362181","autoplay":false,"expect_preroll":true,"pInstance":"p53","plugins":"comscore":"clientId":"6036439","c3":"kxan.com","version":"5.2.0","useDerivedMetadata":true,"mapping":"c3":"kxan.com","ns_st_st":"kxan","ns_st_pu":"Nexstar","ns_st_ge":"News,Local,Austin,Video,Local News,Video","cs_ucfr":"","dfp":"adTagUrl":"https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ads?sz=1×1000&iu=/5678/lin.kxan/news/local/austin&impl=s&gdfp_req=1&env=vp&output=vmap&unviewed_position_start=1&ad_rule=1&description_url=https://www.kxan.com/news/local/austin/protest-related-indictment-against-austin-police-officer-dismissed/&cust_params=vid%3D8362181%26cmsid%3D1638720%26pid%3D1638720%26pers_cid%3Dnxs-40-article-1638720%26vidcat%3D/news/local/austin%26bob_ck%3D[bob_ck_val]%26d_code%3D1%26pagetype%3Dstory%26hlmeta%3Dprotest%20related%20indictment%20against%20austin%20police%20officer%20dismissed%26aa%3Df","nielsen":"apid":"P74D95DB2-9ACC-40E2-B3B5-7B9C65C50126","sfcode":"dcr","type":"dcr","apn":"Anvato","environment":"production","useDerivedMetadata":true,"mapping":"adloadtype":2,"adModel":2,"segmentCustom":"script":"https://segment.psg.nexstardigital.net/anvato.js","writeKey":"8Jlo8JuUyENFG8nvLkq1NuyT2CHRyOp7","pluginsLoadingTimeout":12,"expectPrerollTimeout":8,"accessKey":"gq261XAmw8b5xi69ku8hYmO1kyPmMBzn","token":"eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJ2aWQiOiI4MzYyMTgxIiwiaXNzIjoiZ3EyNjFYQW13OGI1eGk2OWt1OGhZbU8xa3lQbU1Cem4iLCJleHAiOjE2NzU1Mjc3MTR9.Z20u99SJeHtlMa4fplSyxKk53k5MOLnPTpIsPI4NOnY","nxs":"mp4Url":"https://tkx.mp.lura.live/rest/v2/mcp/video/8362181?anvack=bvJ0dQpmRLZx7cMPeiW9U27gVRARwpPL&token=%7E5iu%2Fc5IPbES%2BNStRb12iX7loGseZvo70MQ%3D%3D","enableFloatingPlayer":true,"disableMutedAutoplay":false,"recommendations":false,"expectPreroll":false,"titleVisible":false,"pauseOnClick":true,"trackTimePeriod":60,"isPermutiveEnabled":true
// –>


Tracking the Coronavirus


COVID-19 tracker: Cases in the KXAN viewing area

/ 19 hours ago


Data tracker: COVID cases, vaccine rates across Texas

/ 19 hours ago


Coronavirus Cases Tracker

Austin Weather

Current

40°

Fog

Tonight

45°

Partly Cloudy

Precip: 0&percnt;

Tomorrow

72°

Partly Cloudy

Precip: 0&percnt;

Trending Stories


Frustrated neighbors still without power in West …


Boil water notices for parts of Hays, Travis, Bastrop


Austin Energy ‘cautiously optimistic’ on restoration


MAP: Tracking power outages


Why don’t we just bury the power lines?

Don’t Miss


Why don’t we just bury the power lines?


Radio signal detected from distant galaxy


TxDMV rejects vegan license plate for ‘vulgar’ phrase


KXAN launches new news podcasts



Latest weather conditions from the KXAN First Warning Weather team