Case dismissed of a man sentenced to 60 years in prison over ‘unreliable’ DNA analysis

AUSTIN (KXAN) – Travis County District Attorney José Garza announced this week that his office would dismiss a case of a man who was accused of attacking a woman with a brick in a downtown office building over a decade ago. 

The man was accused of the offense in Feb. 2011 and was indicted by a Travis County Grand Jury shortly after. One year later, a Travis County Jury convicted the accused of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and sentenced him to 60 years in prison. However, years later, Travis county officials determined that DNA evidence used to convict the man was “inconclusive” and “unreliable.” 

On Wednesday, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals overturned the conviction.


Travis County gets more than $500K to help sift through potentially botched Austin Police DNA cases

“The process to review cases stemming from the APD DNA lab involved stakeholders from the city, the county, forensic experts, the defense and the prosecution. We believe the victim, in this case, was assaulted in a parking garage; however, due to the unreliability of the DNA evidence presented at trial, we cannot prove who committed the assault,” Garza said. 

“Our hearts go out to the family of the victim who have had to watch this process unfold, and we are grateful to all the stakeholders for the care and attention they paid to [the] case to see that justice was done.” 

In 2016, the Texas Forensic Science Commission conducted an audit of the Austin Police Department and found significant problems – including “using an unaccepted scientific method for evaluating DNA, inadequate supervision of analysts, and practices in place that encouraged confirmation bias of result, according to a Travis County press release. 


Forensics lab will soon be independent from Austin Police Department

Lawyers who worked with the accused raised concerns in 2018 about the reliability of the DNA interpretations. Last year, the man in the case was able to walk free on bond.

Travis County officials said this is the second previously convicted person to claim evidence from the APD DNA lab used against them resulted in a wrongful conviction and prison sentence.

 

Travis County District Attorney’s Office (KXAN Photo)
Travis County District Attorney’s Office (KXAN Photo)

AUSTIN (KXAN) – Travis County District Attorney José Garza announced this week that his office would dismiss a case of a man who was accused of attacking a woman with a brick in a downtown office building over a decade ago. 

The man was accused of the offense in Feb. 2011 and was indicted by a Travis County Grand Jury shortly after. One year later, a Travis County Jury convicted the accused of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and sentenced him to 60 years in prison. However, years later, Travis county officials determined that DNA evidence used to convict the man was “inconclusive” and “unreliable.” 

On Wednesday, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals overturned the conviction.


Travis County gets more than $500K to help sift through potentially botched Austin Police DNA cases

“The process to review cases stemming from the APD DNA lab involved stakeholders from the city, the county, forensic experts, the defense and the prosecution. We believe the victim, in this case, was assaulted in a parking garage; however, due to the unreliability of the DNA evidence presented at trial, we cannot prove who committed the assault,” Garza said. 

“Our hearts go out to the family of the victim who have had to watch this process unfold, and we are grateful to all the stakeholders for the care and attention they paid to [the] case to see that justice was done.” 

In 2016, the Texas Forensic Science Commission conducted an audit of the Austin Police Department and found significant problems – including “using an unaccepted scientific method for evaluating DNA, inadequate supervision of analysts, and practices in place that encouraged confirmation bias of result, according to a Travis County press release. 


Forensics lab will soon be independent from Austin Police Department

Lawyers who worked with the accused raised concerns in 2018 about the reliability of the DNA interpretations. Last year, the man in the case was able to walk free on bond.

Travis County officials said this is the second previously convicted person to claim evidence from the APD DNA lab used against them resulted in a wrongful conviction and prison sentence.

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

<article class="article-list__article" data-article-id="1307096" data-index="0" data-collection="article-list1" data-anvato-params=""pauseOnTabInactive":false
// –>

Tracking the Coronavirus


What is the current COVID risk in your county?

/ 1 day ago

Austin Weather

Current

77°

Fair

Tonight

60°

Mostly Cloudy

Precip: 0&percnt;

Tomorrow

86°

Isolated Thunderstorms

Precip: 20&percnt;

Trending Stories


Body pulled from Lady Bird Lake Saturday, APD confirms


Texas DPS Chief EEO officer suspended after arrest


Heavy congestion expected near UT, downtown


APD releases video of gas station shooting, robbery


Large swath of land donated for conservancy

Don’t Miss


KXAN’s beloved Kaxan dies after brain cancer battle


Traffic: How to get around CMT Awards in Austin


2023 already off to a record start at Austin airport


RESULTS: This is the best KXAN viewer pic of February


KXAN launches new news podcasts



Latest weather conditions from the KXAN First Warning Weather team