Election 2024: A Wake-up Call for the Left?

  

Donald Trump caught his white whale. He was not only sent back to the White House, but he did so with (as of this writing) over 300 electoral votes and a significant lead in the popular vote. Trump has never won the popular vote, and it’s the first time a Republican has in 20 years.

Couple Trump’s victory with the Republican Party running up the score in the Senate and, perhaps, in the House, and you have a clear picture of just how much voters have rejected the Democratic Party.

The 2024 presidential election has sent a clear message to the Democrats: Americans are tired of being talked down to. In a stunning rebuke, voters across the country rejected Kamala Harris and a Democratic Party that seemed more interested in lecturing and dividing than understanding and uniting. 

This defeat wasn’t about Donald Trump’s popularity or any newfound love for Republicans. It was about a growing frustration with the Democrats’ priorities and messaging, and it’s a lesson the party and its allies in the media ignore at their own peril.

1. Voters Don’t Want to Be Lectured To

For the past year or so, Democrats have insisted that the economy was doing just fine. They pointed to data showing growth, low unemployment rates, and corporate earnings, all while Americans watched their grocery bills skyrocket, their rent go through the roof, and their energy costs strain household budgets. When voters expressed concern about the rising cost of living, Democrats were quick to downplay those anxieties, often suggesting that people just didn’t understand how well things were actually going.

This approach backfired in a big way. Voters don’t want to be told that their concerns are invalid or that they’re wrong for feeling economic pain. When the party in power refuses to acknowledge the everyday struggles of working Americans, it creates a disconnect — and in 2024, that disconnect was more than enough to push many voters away from the Democratic Party.

Instead of engaging with real concerns, the Democrats relied on data points and rosy reports that sounded out of touch to a lot of people struggling to make ends meet. By doing so, they reinforced the perception that they’ve become the party of elites who are insulated from the realities faced by everyday Americans.

But their attitude toward American voters about the economy was just a symptom of the Democrats’ key problem: They chose to lecture and scold Americans rather than make any meaningful connection with them. They scolded Americans who supported Trump, lectured black men who didn’t support Harris, and criticized a country that would dare to even think about electing someone like Trump.

2. Identity Politics Alienated More Than It Helped

The Democratic Party in recent years has doubled down on identity politics, attempting to appeal to voters by segmenting them into demographic groups based on race, gender, and sexual orientation. But in 2024, this approach didn’t resonate the way Democrats hoped. Voters want to be seen as Americans, not as boxes to be checked off on a diversity spreadsheet. They care about issues that impact their daily lives — jobs, safety, education, and healthcare — and they don’t appreciate being pigeonholed based on identity alone.

The Democrats’ reliance on identity-based appeals felt divisive and shallow, especially to working-class Americans who often feel overlooked by both parties. The Democrats seemed more interested in virtue-signaling than in addressing the bread-and-butter issues that affect everyone, regardless of race or gender. This approach may have helped the Democrats among certain demographics in the past, but in 2024, it turned off a significant portion of the electorate who were tired of being categorized and preached to.

There is a palpable exhaustion among minority voters who want to be treated as Americans rather than as a demographic. The Democrats’ need to try to please multiple different (and often at-odds) groups led to frustration.

3. The Abortion Issue Didn’t Sway Voters Like Democrats Hoped

Going into the election, Democrats placed a heavy emphasis on abortion rights, expecting it to be a decisive issue. But when voters went to the polls, it turned out that abortion wasn’t the all-encompassing motivator Democrats thought it would be. Polls showed that while Americans support some degree of reproductive freedom, they also prioritize other issues, particularly as economic conditions worsen.

Harris, as a woman, tried to play up the reproductive justice/abortion rights angle, but it seemed to fall flat. To be somewhat fair to her, Republicans in the immediate aftermath of the Dobbs decision were like the dog that finally caught the car – they had no idea what to do next. But, multiple election cycles later, and the American public has seen several states set their own abortion laws in place, and they are no longer treating it as a key voting issue like they were. Democrats held on to the issue longer than they should have.

The Democratic Party’s single-minded focus on abortion left them vulnerable on other fronts. They failed to address the issues that matter most to voters’ day-to-day lives, like the economy, crime, and the border crisis. In the end, voters sent a message: they are more concerned with making ends meet, feeling safe in their communities, and ensuring a stable future than with the Democrats’ attempts to turn every election into a referendum on Roe v. Wade.

4. Erosion of Key Demographics Signals a Crisis for the Democrats

One of the biggest red flags for Democrats this election cycle was their dramatic loss of support among several key demographics. Black men, Hispanic voters (particularly Hispanic men), young men, and married women all shifted away from the Democratic Party in significant numbers. This shift isn’t just a blip on the radar; it’s a warning sign that the Democratic coalition is fraying.

These groups, many of them historically reliable for Democrats, are signaling that the party is no longer connecting with them. For Black and Hispanic men, the Democratic Party’s focus on social issues over economic ones — combined with a perception of disrespect toward traditional values — left them disillusioned. 

Young men, in particular, are increasingly turned off by a party that they see as scolding and dismissive. And married women, who often prioritize safety, stability, and family issues, found themselves alienated by a Democratic Party more concerned with identity politics than practical solutions.

If the Democrats don’t reassess their message, they risk losing these groups for good.

5. Democrats Have Abandoned the Working Class to the GOP

There was a time when the Democratic Party could confidently claim to be the party of the working class. But in 2024, that mantle has largely shifted to the Republicans. Today, the Democrats are increasingly seen as the party of educated elites — people in academia, tech, media, and coastal enclaves who are often far removed from the day-to-day realities of working-class life.

While Republicans have been rallying around issues that resonate with blue-collar Americans — like jobs, inflation, and local manufacturing — Democrats have focused on progressive social policies that don’t speak to the working class. The GOP’s shift to embrace populist themes and economic nationalism has allowed them to reach working-class voters who feel that the Democrats no longer represent their interests.

For a party that once thrived on the support of unions, factory workers, and rural communities, this shift is a devastating blow. Democrats have allowed themselves to become the party of elites, and they are paying the price.

A Warning for the Democrats (and the Media)

The 2024 election wasn’t just a defeat for Kamala Harris; it was a referendum on a Democratic Party that has lost touch with the American people. Voters are tired of being talked down to, tired of identity politics, and tired of a party that seems more concerned with social crusades than with practical solutions for everyday life.

If Democrats — and their allies in the media — want to win back the trust of the American people, they need to stop lecturing and start listening. Americans want leaders who understand their concerns, not elites who dismiss or minimize them. Until the Democrats recognize this fundamental truth, they’re likely to keep losing elections. The American people have spoken, and it’s time for the Democratic Party to take the message to heart.