Texas judge will make a ruling that could ban abortion pills nationwide

AMARILLO, Texas (KXAN) — A decision on whether to reverse a Food and Drug Administration approval of mifepristone, a pill used to end pregnancies, has been pushed back until at least Feb. 24. The decision, which some previously expected to come as soon as Friday, could affect access to the medication across the country. 

Approved by the FDA in 2000, the drug is available by mail, telemedicine and pharmacy pickup. Mifepristone is one of two medications used to terminate pregnancies, and already over 29 states, including Texas, have laws or restrictions on the use of the medication, according to Guttmacher, a reproductive health research and policy organization.

Lawyers from the Alliance for Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian legal advocacy group, filed the lawsuit on Nov. 18 in an Amarillo federal court on behalf of four anti-abortion plaintiffs. 

“Pregnancy is not an illness, and chemical abortion drugs don’t provide a therapeutic benefit — they end a baby’s life and they pose serious and life-threatening complications to the mother,” said Alliance for Defending Freedom Senior Counsel Julie Marie Blake in a November press release.

“The FDA never had the authority to approve these dangerous drugs for sale. We urge the court to listen to the doctors we represent who are seeking to protect girls and women from the documented dangers of chemical abortion drugs,” the press release continued. 

Texas District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk could side with the plaintiffs and grant an emergency injunction forcing the FDA to revoke its approval of mifepristone. Abortion advocates said this would pull the drug from the market and effectively initiate a nationwide ban on the medication. 

“Medication abortion is the most commonly used method of abortion. Banning mifepristone nationwide would have severe consequences on people’s ability to access critical abortion and miscarriage care,” wrote the Nation Abortion Rights Action League on its website. 

“Abortion access in our country is already in crisis after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. If this judge takes medication abortion off the market, even more people will lose the freedom to make their own decisions about their lives, bodies and futures,” it continued. 

CNBC reported Judge Kacsmaryk ordered Danco Laboratories, a manufacturer of mifepristone, to lay out its opposition to removing the medication for the U.S. market. The anti-abortion physicians will then have until Feb. 24 to respond.

David Donatti, a staff attorney for ACLU Texas, said mifepristone is now used in about half of all abortions executed in the U.S. and has had a stellar safety record in its decades of active use. He said mifepristone is considered to be as safe as Tylenol.

“These plaintiff groups have no injury whatsoever to themselves, they have no standing to sue or challenge the FDA regulations here,” he said. “This case should not see the light of day, and it’s very much my hope that Judge Kacsmaryk sees that.”

Donatti said this lawsuit poses institutional risks as well.

“Here you would have an unelected judge with no scientific or medical background making a decision that counters not only the weight of 20 years of American science, but the weight of science across the world,” Donatti said.

“These are difficult decisions that require weighing a lot of information. They require analyses by scientists and peer-reviewed journals. And this is just truly not the province of lawyers.”

 

FILE – Boxes of the drug mifepristone sit on a shelf at the West Alabama Women’s Center in Tuscaloosa, Ala., on March 16, 2022. Attorney generals…

FILE – Boxes of the drug mifepristone sit on a shelf at the West Alabama Women’s Center in Tuscaloosa, Ala., on March 16, 2022. Attorney generals in 20 conservative-led states warned CVS and Walgreens on Wednesday, Feb. 1, 2023, that they could face legal consequences if they sell abortion pills by mail in those states. (AP Photo/Allen G. Breed, File)

AMARILLO, Texas (KXAN) — A decision on whether to reverse a Food and Drug Administration approval of mifepristone, a pill used to end pregnancies, has been pushed back until at least Feb. 24. The decision, which some previously expected to come as soon as Friday, could affect access to the medication across the country. 

Approved by the FDA in 2000, the drug is available by mail, telemedicine and pharmacy pickup. Mifepristone is one of two medications used to terminate pregnancies, and already over 29 states, including Texas, have laws or restrictions on the use of the medication, according to Guttmacher, a reproductive health research and policy organization.

Lawyers from the Alliance for Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian legal advocacy group, filed the lawsuit on Nov. 18 in an Amarillo federal court on behalf of four anti-abortion plaintiffs. 

“Pregnancy is not an illness, and chemical abortion drugs don’t provide a therapeutic benefit — they end a baby’s life and they pose serious and life-threatening complications to the mother,” said Alliance for Defending Freedom Senior Counsel Julie Marie Blake in a November press release.

“The FDA never had the authority to approve these dangerous drugs for sale. We urge the court to listen to the doctors we represent who are seeking to protect girls and women from the documented dangers of chemical abortion drugs,” the press release continued. 

Texas District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk could side with the plaintiffs and grant an emergency injunction forcing the FDA to revoke its approval of mifepristone. Abortion advocates said this would pull the drug from the market and effectively initiate a nationwide ban on the medication. 

“Medication abortion is the most commonly used method of abortion. Banning mifepristone nationwide would have severe consequences on people’s ability to access critical abortion and miscarriage care,” wrote the Nation Abortion Rights Action League on its website. 

“Abortion access in our country is already in crisis after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. If this judge takes medication abortion off the market, even more people will lose the freedom to make their own decisions about their lives, bodies and futures,” it continued. 

CNBC reported Judge Kacsmaryk ordered Danco Laboratories, a manufacturer of mifepristone, to lay out its opposition to removing the medication for the U.S. market. The anti-abortion physicians will then have until Feb. 24 to respond.

David Donatti, a staff attorney for ACLU Texas, said mifepristone is now used in about half of all abortions executed in the U.S. and has had a stellar safety record in its decades of active use. He said mifepristone is considered to be as safe as Tylenol.

“These plaintiff groups have no injury whatsoever to themselves, they have no standing to sue or challenge the FDA regulations here,” he said. “This case should not see the light of day, and it’s very much my hope that Judge Kacsmaryk sees that.”

Donatti said this lawsuit poses institutional risks as well.

“Here you would have an unelected judge with no scientific or medical background making a decision that counters not only the weight of 20 years of American science, but the weight of science across the world,” Donatti said.

“These are difficult decisions that require weighing a lot of information. They require analyses by scientists and peer-reviewed journals. And this is just truly not the province of lawyers.”

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Single on Valentine’s Day? Here are 13 gifts to buy …

/ 3 hours ago

Check out these fabulous gifts to give yourself this Valentine’s Day if you want to enjoy the holiday a little more.


These 13 Valentine’s Day gifts are great for a new …

/ 3 hours ago

For people in new relationships, the stakes often feel very high, because the pressure to impress is increased.


20 Valentine’s Day gifts for the woman who has everything

/ 2 hours ago

Valentine’s Day is right around the corner, which means it’s time to start thinking about how to treat the special woman in your life.


View All BestReviews


Top Stories


Suspect wanted after robbing 2 banks, APD says


Austin to part ways with City Manager Spencer Cronk


Cool, dry weekend ahead of next rain maker


APD: No threat from reported ‘suspicious package’


City waives some repair, utility fees after ice storm


Top Stories


More Stories


Suspect wanted after robbing 2 banks, APD says


Austin to part ways with City Manager Spencer Cronk


Cool, dry weekend ahead of next rain maker


TX judge may make decision banning abortion pills …


APD: No threat from reported ‘suspicious package’


City waives some repair, utility fees after ice storm


Moontower Just For Laughs lineup expands


Mother of man shot by police makes plea to City Council


More Stories

Austin-Travis County


Suspect wanted after robbing 2 banks, APD says

/ 1 hour ago


Austin to part ways with City Manager Spencer Cronk

/ 2 hours ago


Cool, dry weekend ahead of next rain maker

/ 27 mins ago


APD: No threat from reported ‘suspicious package’

/ 2 hours ago


City waives some repair, utility fees after ice storm

/ 3 hours ago


Moontower Just For Laughs lineup expands

/ 3 hours ago


Mother of man shot by police makes plea to City Council

/ 2 hours ago


ATCEMS program helps patients during outages

/ 4 hours ago


ATX has $29M to improve roads – here’s the plan

/ 3 hours ago


Texas gives interim coach Rodney Terry raise to $1.2M

/ 7 hours ago


Mental health screening service opens on ACC campus

/ 8 hours ago


AFD: Cat dead in fire

/ 9 hours ago


Duran Duran coming to ATX

/ 9 hours ago


You need 5 min. wage jobs to afford an Austin apartment

/ 8 hours ago


Thousands briefly lose power again in south Austin

/ 8 hours ago


Weather radios down following ice storm

/ 8 hours ago


APH to open cold weather shelters Friday night

/ 2 hours ago


Motorcycle hits building on 6th Street

/ 7 hours ago


1 arrested after driving onto Texas Capitol grounds

/ 4 hours ago


Austin zoo expects months of cleanup after ice storm

/ 22 hours ago

KXAN Austin Video

<article class="article-list__article article-list__article–is-stacked article-list__article–has-thumb article-list__article–is-media-type" data-article-id="8380700" data-index="0" data-collection="article-list5" data-anvato-params=""ns":"id":"8380700","title":"Mother of man shot, killed by police pleads for City Council to address police violence","link":"https://www.kxan.com/video/mother-of-man-shot-killed-by-police-pleads-for-city-council-to-address-police-violence/8380700/","thumbnail":"src":"https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ","orientation":"landscape","proportional_sources":"16:9":"srcset":"https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 160w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 256w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 320w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 640w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 960w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 1280w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 1920w, https://m104216-ucdn.mp.lura.live/iupl_lin/6AC/543/6AC54380702BFEA8034D94B4891C1F6E_160x90.jpg?Expires=2082758400&KeyName=mcpkey1&Signature=AdGP2vYQOS0evJZgNdwwzu_t3IQ 2560w","sizes":"(max-width: 899px) 100%, 300px","date":"time":"2 hours ago","datetime":"2023-02-10T13:55:00-06:00","lead_media":true,"media_type_icon":"name":"video","label":"Video","vilynx_id":"LIN_8380700","mcp":"LIN","width":"100%","height":"100%","video":"8380700","autoplay":false,"expect_preroll":true,"pInstance":"p48","plugins":"comscore":"clientId":"6036439","c3":"kxan.com","version":"5.2.0","useDerivedMetadata":true,"mapping":"c3":"kxan.com","ns_st_st":"kxan","ns_st_pu":"Nexstar","ns_st_ge":"News,Local,Austin,Video,Local News,Video","cs_ucfr":"","dfp":"adTagUrl":"https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ads?sz=1×1000&iu=/5678/lin.kxan/news/texas&impl=s&gdfp_req=1&env=vp&output=vmap&unviewed_position_start=1&ad_rule=1&description_url=https://www.kxan.com/news/texas/texas-judge-will-make-a-ruling-this-month-that-could-ban-abortion-pills-nationwide/&cust_params=vid%3D8380700%26cmsid%3D1647127%26pid%3D1647127%26pers_cid%3Dnxs-40-article-1647127%26vidcat%3D/news/texas%26bob_ck%3D[bob_ck_val]%26d_code%3D1%26pagetype%3Dstory%26hlmeta%3Dtexas%20judge%20will%20make%20a%20ruling%20this%20month%20that%20could%20ban%20abortion%20pills%20nationwide%26aa%3Df","nielsen":"apid":"P74D95DB2-9ACC-40E2-B3B5-7B9C65C50126","sfcode":"dcr","type":"dcr","apn":"Anvato","environment":"production","useDerivedMetadata":true,"mapping":"adloadtype":2,"adModel":2,"segmentCustom":"script":"https://segment.psg.nexstardigital.net/anvato.js","writeKey":"8Jlo8JuUyENFG8nvLkq1NuyT2CHRyOp7","pluginsLoadingTimeout":12,"expectPrerollTimeout":8,"accessKey":"gq261XAmw8b5xi69ku8hYmO1kyPmMBzn","token":"eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJ2aWQiOiI4MzgwNzAwIiwiaXNzIjoiZ3EyNjFYQW13OGI1eGk2OWt1OGhZbU8xa3lQbU1Cem4iLCJleHAiOjE2NzYwNzA2Nzd9.GgthYUmgx5P8jjRVNVzzD2domVJ3SkxE-lhNXLmC6HM","nxs":"mp4Url":"https://tkx.mp.lura.live/rest/v2/mcp/video/8380700?anvack=bvJ0dQpmRLZx7cMPeiW9U27gVRARwpPL&token=%7E5iuxcZQHbUS%2BNSlVZ1erWbloGseZvo70MQ%3D%3D","enableFloatingPlayer":true,"disableMutedAutoplay":false,"recommendations":false,"expectPreroll":false,"titleVisible":false,"pauseOnClick":true,"trackTimePeriod":60,"isPermutiveEnabled":true
// –>


Tracking the Coronavirus


COVID-19 tracker: Cases in the KXAN viewing area

/ 2 days ago


Data tracker: COVID cases, vaccine rates across Texas

/ 2 days ago


Coronavirus Cases Tracker

Austin Weather

Current

54°

Sunny

Tonight

34°

Mostly Clear

Precip: 0&percnt;

Tomorrow

58°

Sunny

Precip: 0&percnt;

Trending Stories


Austin to part ways with City Manager Spencer Cronk


Replacement SNAP benefits available after winter …


APD: No threat from reported ‘suspicious package’


You need 5 min. wage jobs to afford an Austin apartment


Paxton settles with former aides who reported him …

Don’t Miss


RESULTS: This is the best KXAN viewer pic of January


Can I burn my tree stumps, fallen branches post-storm?


TxDMV rejects vegan license plate for ‘vulgar’ phrase


Cities offer free tree, brush disposals post-storm


KXAN launches new news podcasts



Latest weather conditions from the KXAN First Warning Weather team